August 29, 2010

The Wakf (Amendment) Bill, 2010

Recall that in the Sachar Committee Report, extensive recommendation were made to amend and modify the law relating to Wakf.  Further to the same, the Wakf (Amendment) Bill, 2010 was introduced in the Lok Sabha on April 27, 2010 by the Minister of Minority Affairs, Shri Salman Kurshid.  The Bill has already been passed by the Lok Sabha on May 7, 2010 and is presently pending in the Rajya Sabha. The Bill seeks to amend the Wakf Act, 1995 that provides for administration of Wakfs.  

Broadly, the objective of the amendments is to limit the intervention by the Government and to give certain powers to the Wakf Board to take summary actions to protect and secure Wakf Property.

PRS Legislative Brief for the Wakf (Amendment) Bill, 2010 is available here.  Further perspectives on the same are available here.  A further insight into the working of Wakf Boards (that obviously needs to be corrected) is available here.


May 29, 2010

Fatwa against participation of Muslims Women in Employment


Current issue of EPW (May 22-28, 2010) carries an article by Yoginder Sikand on Deoband’s Fatwas on Women which discussed the recent fatwa issued by the Deoband Dar ul-Uloom’s recent fatwa againt Muslim women working outside the home and a host of other women-related fatwas close almost all sources of employment, which even extends to participation of muslim women in education. The said article can be downloaded from here.

Separate from the issue of validity of the fatwa and its connection with the economic realities of the Muslim community, it is pertinent to note that absence of exclusive educational facilities for Muslim girls has been discussed in Sachar Commitee Report as one of the reasons for why Muslim women do not participate in proportionate numbers in schools/colleges.

May 21, 2010

Identity Politics in J&K: The Intersection of Regional and Communal

Rekha Chowdhary (Professor, Political Science, Jammu University) in an article in May 8, 2010 issue of EPW, discusses the intersection of the regional and communal identity of politics that characterizes the two Bills introduced in the recently concluded budget session of Jammu and Kashmir (J&K) Legislature. She writes that both the Permanent Resident (Disqualification) Bill, 2010 that seeks to disqualify the J&K women from their permanent residential status if they marry outside the state and the Inter-District Recruitment Bill, which aims to ban the inter-district recruitment, are not simplistic or homogeneous issues with singular nature. The debate on both issues, instead of revolving around the effect of such change on the substantive rights of the parties that come under their purview, has been hijacked by the competitive politics of regional/religious identity, which has come to define the J&K political discourse.

The PR Disqualification bill has received support in Kashmir cutting across party lines, both from the mainstream politicians as well as separatists. The opposition has come from Jammu where it has been opposed not as being discriminatory in general but as ‘anti- Jammu’ and ‘anti-Hindu’. The debate, riding on emotive examples, has been on ‘dangerous regional and communal lines’ and has completely sidelined the ‘rights of women’. Similarly, the discourse on the Inter-District Recruitment Bill has centred on communal and regional identities where Kashmir has been pitted against Jammu. The demand was initially raised to preserve the interests of the backward districts of the state to ban ‘outsiders’ from usurping employment opportunities, but got pitted against the backward communities who have the benefit of reservation. The political parties in Kashmir, displaying regional favouritism, went on to demand the withdrawal of reservation for Dalits as Kashmir being predominantly Muslim does not have any Scheduled Case (SC) population. On the other hand, the Jammu based parties who were initially at the forefront, demanding a Bill banning the inter-district recruitment started called it ‘anti- Jammu’ and against Hindus.

The author puts these two issues in the backdrop of the increasingly ‘regional polarized response’, even from Kashmir. Unlike Jammu, this is uncharacteristic of Kashmiri politics, where the response to public issues has historically been articulated with the Kashmir’s reference to India. But now a regional aspect of ‘discrimination vis-à-vis Jammu has also been added to the earlier dimension. She attributes this high-pitched, regionally and communally polarized politics as a ‘fallout of the increasing relevance of the politics of governance and the intensity of competition’; and with parties ‘competing for the same political space, they tend to radicalize the politics and in the process increase sensitivities about identity’.

Taking an even more vicious turn, the region-based politics has not remained exclusively limited to the cries of ‘discrimination or ‘dangers of demographic change’ that diverts ‘all political energies to divisive positions and reduces substantial issues to simplistic notions of regional discrimination’ , but has also acquired communal overtones where the regional identity is often used interchangeably with religious connotations. Kashmir gets equated with Muslims and Jammu with Hindus. The arguments about the regional discrimination transcend to religion and are employed by the politicians to ‘stoke barely camouflaged communal sentiments.’ The outcome is that identity politics starts getting defined on the basis of the religious character and hence the ‘need to preserve it’.

The intersection and seamless transition of the divisive nature of the indentity politics based on regional and religious divisiveness from one form to another on any issue not only diverts attention from concerns of good governance, but also undermines the unity and integrity of the state, and does great harm to cherished cultural, plural and secular values, one example being Amarnath agitation of 2008. To quote Chowdhary, “For a socially and culturally diverse state like J&K, there is a fundamental danger in the deepening of identity politics polarized along regional and communal lines. It will not merely weaken the secular basis and plural ethos of the state, but also endanger the very integrity of the state by fracturing the relations between its constitutive regions and communities.”

April 27, 2010

Fall of Old Hyderabad: Recent Communal Riots and The Larger Picture

In a very well-written piece in its April 24, 2010 issue, an EPW Correspondent critically analyses the reasons behind the recent communal riots in Old City, Hyderabad. He blames the secular parties for abandoning the areas that has given a communal colour to the politics led by the local Majlis-e-Ittehadul Muslimeen or the Majlis Party that has led to revival of Hindu communalism as well. He documents the history and the reasons for the rise in the communal temper of the city over the years. The article analyses how the city known “ganga-jamni tehzeeb” (cosmopolitan culture) has lost its sheen with time and cites specific instances of how communal riots were exploited by mainstream parties for political gains. The article explains the rise of the Majlis Party because of the reluctance on the part of the secular parties to counter them. The article laments the fact that “far from making any attempt to bring about visible changes, it appears as if the Congress and its government have left the political space of the Old City to the Majlis.”

The article also puts the blame of the rapid communalization on the long-lasting administrative neglect of the Old City. The Old City was the seat of power and government for centuries until the administrative shift began a history of neglect of the region. The shift started in 1930s with the Nizam moving to the new city and continued after independence and accelerated with the formation of Andhra Pradesh in 1956 that led to migration of Telugu-speaking people to Hyderabad who were culturally different from their Urdu-speaking counterparts and “the alienation was complete, as the new democratically elected rulers after 1956, thought that the way of governing the Old City was to follow a policy of benign neglect at best and one of active deprivation at worst.”

The resultant poor governance levels, severe neglect of basic and higher education, shift of political locus and rise of anti-social elements have culminated led to the fall of the Old City where ‘no respect for rule of law’ is left. The correspondent sums up the state of affairs in the Old City at the present - “For all practical purposes, the decaying Old City has been left to rot and deteriorate, completing the process of ghettoisation – a fertile ground for any trouble, communal or otherwise. All it requires is a spark, or a flag as recent events show.”

April 21, 2010

Harsh Mander on Gujarat 2002

Upendra Baxi has reviewed the recently published book titled “Fear and Forgiveness: The Aftermath of Massacre” by Harsh Mander in April 3, 2010 issue of Economic and Political Weekly (EPW). He describes the publication of this book itself as a “solemn event in terms of our commitment to and solidarity with the Gujarat 2002 violated and the survivors’ quest for human rights and justice.” The book highlights the tension created by the competitive plebiscitary democracy and its adverse impact on the position of the human rights and human rights violation of the vulnerable communities. Harsh Mander has tried to resurrect the memory of the Mahatma by a unique moral invention of Nyayagraha. “This invention owes much to the understanding of the four pillars of any future-oriented quest for authentic process of reconciliation. These are: acknowledgment; remorse; repara­tion; and justice. Nyayagraha con­stitutes a remarkable call for the pursuit of ‘legal justice’ conceived not so much as ‘retribution’ but rather as an important articulation of equal citizenship rights”

Baxi notes that the book contains references to a series of independent reports on Gujarat riots in 2002 that “gathered system­atic evidence of the enormity of brutality, long advance preparations for the car­nage, the deliberate subversion of relief, rehabilitation, and the legal process, and the comprehensive denial of the [human] rights of the persons internally displaced by violence”. He further notices that Mander instead of indulging Gujarat bashing also brings messages of hope and reconstruction by by highlighting the fact that how, many families risked their life to provide shelter to the hapless Muslims under attack.

Mander deplores the political appropriation of the ‘Gujarati Asmita’ which he describes as “an aspect of collective moral sentiment according respect and dignity to all living beings. It is a cultural, even civilization, legacy, not any project of militant politics directed to any violent social exclusion of Gujarati peoples on the basis of caste, creed, colour, or religion.”


Mander tries to understand the tendency of perpetrating 'mass murders' as an instrument to capture power by modern states. In India, it is characterized by inundated with ineffective commissions of inquiry. Lack of accountability and due process allows such inhuman acts to be committed with impunity in total disregard to governance ethics.


The book also aims at understanding the “neo-Nazi” politics in India and draws a parallel between neo -Nazi politics and “Moditva”, both of which ‘consists in re-victimizing the victims’. As a logical corollary Baxi finds, “the ideology governing neo-Nazi politics stands directed towards violent social exclusion of vulnerable social groups, especially religion and language-based cultural collectivities and “sexually despised” minorities…. In this, it reflects social conservatism opposed in each and every specific way to the constitutional idea of an egalitarian Indian republic.”

Housing Quota for Muslims?

The Minority View had earlier raised the issue of discrimination and ghettoism in housings for Muslims. Political leaders are now alive of the matter, and it seems that the Maharashtra Government may soon set  up a specialized body to assess the need and feasibility for quota for Muslims. The statements made by Mr. Sharad Pawar can be accessed here, and here . 

The Minority View appreciates the proposed evidence and need based intervention of the Government. 

April 11, 2010

How to Harmonise? : Prohibition of Child Marriage Act versus Muslim Personal Law

The recently enacted Prohibition of Child Marriage Act (PCMA), 2006 which prohibits a marriage under the age of 18 has come into conflict with the Indian Muslim Personal laws on the subject, that allows a person to marry after attainment of puberty and recognizes the age of 15 for the same.

The issue surfaced when the wedding of a Muslim girl was stopped by police, in Ghatkopar , Mumbai, after they received a complaint alleging violation of the PCMA Act as she was only 15. Later, the mother of the girl filed a habeus corpus petition seeking custody of the girl who was sent to the Child Welfare Home. Awaaz-e-Niswan, an NGO, has urged the Bombay High Court to uphold the PCMA over the Muslim personal Law and filed an intervention application in the matter. The All India Muslim Personal Law Board (AIMPLB) has also been made a party. It will be interesting to see what stand the AIMPLB takes on the matter.

The outcome of this decision bears much significance in the wider legal context, because of the place the ‘personal laws’ occupy in the Indian constitutional framework. The personal laws are immune to challenge as they are exempted under the definition of ‘law’ under Article 13 of the Constitution. (An earlier post also reflects the dichotomous position the judiciary finds itself in , when dealing with personal laws.) The Courts have, however in the recent past, tried to give effect to such social welfare provisions, terming them ‘secular’ and thereby making them applicable to all sections of the society, for example, the maintenance provision under Section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC), 1973. Therefore , even though the matter still awaits judicial determination, it seems likely that the PCMA Act shall be given precedence over the Muslim personal law.